MADE FOR

Maddy Schultz

Maddy, after looking closely at what's happening at Ability Tree, one thing comes through loud and clear: you're running a real, established organization doing meaningful work — but the people powering it, including you, are running on fumes. You named staff retention as the biggest thing holding you back, and that's exactly right. What follows is an honest look at the three interconnected dynamics that are keeping Ability Tree from the next level of growth and sustainability.

Welcome to your personal Diagnostic

WATCH BEFORE YOU DIVE IN

Jesse Lane founder of goodmakerU, has a message to walk you through your report to let you know whats here, and how to use it.

YOUR TOP THREE GROWTH BLOCKERS

Stretched & Burned Out Team

When you said your team is working unsustainable hours and burnout is showing, that's not a staffing footnote — that's the headline. For an organization your size, running a $501K–$1M budget with only 2–5 full-time staff, the math is brutal. Every person is carrying more than their role was designed to hold. The result isn't just fatigue — it's turnover, and turnover at Ability Tree isn't just an HR problem, it's a mission problem. When institutional knowledge walks out the door, you spend months rebuilding what you already had. Hiring key staff positions landed in your top three priorities for good reason. The question isn't whether you can afford to grow the team — it's whether you can afford not to. Addressing burnout starts with being honest about what's understaffed and building a case, financially and programmatically, for filling those gaps.

Leader-Dependent Nonprofit

You named it yourself: everything important runs through you, and you can't take a break without things falling apart. At Ability Tree, fundraising and donor relationships are almost entirely dependent on your presence — and while that speaks to how much people trust and believe in you personally, it also means the organization's revenue is fragile in a way that doesn't show up on a balance sheet. If you're sick, traveling, or just stretched thin, those relationships go quiet. This isn't a personal failure; it's a structural one. Organizations at your stage often haven't had the bandwidth to build the systems and secondary relationships that distribute that load. But with a small team already maxed out, this bottleneck compounds everything else — because when you're the one doing donor stewardship, grant outreach, and operations triage, there's nothing left for strategy.

Ready to Scale Nonprofit

Here's the truth about Ability Tree: you have real foundations to build on. A diversified funding base, a loyal board that has your back, a decade-plus of credibility in your community, and a retention rate that's right at industry median — none of that is nothing. You're not broken, you're bottlenecked. The reason Ready to Scale lands in your top three is that the infrastructure for growth is underdeveloped relative to where the organization actually is. Diversifying revenue streams made your priority list, and that instinct is right — but pursuing new revenue without fixing the capacity and dependency issues first tends to accelerate the burnout rather than relieve it. The path forward isn't doing more. It's building the systems and team that let Ability Tree grow without requiring heroics from you and your staff every single day.

WHERE YOU'RE AT NOW

These three dynamics don't exist in isolation at Ability Tree — they feed each other in a loop that's worth naming directly. The team is burned out in part because so much runs through you, and so much runs through you in part because there aren't enough people to share the load. Meanwhile, the organization's growth potential is capped not by mission or community need, but by the absence of the systems and staff that would make scaling possible. When your team is stretched, stewardship suffers. When stewardship suffers, donor retention stays flat. When donor retention stays flat, you work harder on acquisition to compensate — which burns out the team further. Breaking this loop requires addressing all three layers, but it starts with capacity: getting the right people in place so the whole system isn't dependent on one point of failure.

YOUR 90 DAY ROAD MAP

  1. Build the business case for your next hire. Before you can bring someone on, you need a clear picture of what role would create the most relief and the most leverage. Map out where your own hours are going each week — specifically the fundraising and donor relationship tasks — and identify what a Development Coordinator or Operations Manager could absorb. Use that data to make the case to your board for funding the position.
  2. Give your board a specific fundraising ask. You said they have your back, and that's a real asset. Now put it to work. Your board's support needs to translate into concrete action — whether that's each member hosting one donor conversation per quarter, helping open doors to corporate prospects, or participating in a specific campaign. Give them a structure, not just a request.
  3. Document your top 10 donor relationships. Since fundraising runs through you, the first step toward distributing that load is capturing what only lives in your head. For your top 10 donors, write down their history, preferences, last touchpoint, and what they care about most. This protects Ability Tree if you're ever unavailable and sets up a future staff member to take over stewardship with confidence.
  4. Identify one new revenue stream to pilot — not five. Diversifying revenue is on your list, and rightly so. But with a maxed-out team, trying to launch multiple new streams will backfire. Pick one — a fee-for-service offering, a recurring giving program, or a new corporate partnership vertical — and run a focused 90-day pilot before committing more resources.
  5. Create a sustainability checkpoint with your team. Schedule a monthly 30-minute check-in specifically about workload and capacity — not program updates. Make it a standing conversation where staff can flag what's unsustainable before it becomes a resignation. This signals that retention is a leadership priority, not just a talking point.
LEARN MORE ABOUT GOODMAKER PRO
Learn MORE

INFORM YOUR TEAM

Get your team and your board in on this conversation. Reports like this one work best when the whole organization can tackle issues together.

Copy Report Link